NEOhio.news Northeast Ohio News & Intelligence

Check Fraud Is at a Record High. Here’s How to Protect Yourself.

Community · Northeast Ohio · June 2, 2026

Check Fraud Is at a Record High. Here’s How to Protect Yourself.

Check fraud is not just a concern for businesses. It is happening to everyday consumers at record levels, and Northeast Ohio residents are not immune.

According to the U.S. Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, check fraud complaints topped two million in 2024, a record high, representing a 4% increase from 2022. Despite the growth of digital payments, checks still account for more than 20% of all noncash transactions in the United States, making them a prime target for criminals.

PNC Bank recently published guidance to help consumers recognize fake checks and take steps to avoid becoming a victim.

How to Tell If a Check Is Fake

Modern technology makes it easier than ever for scammers to produce convincing counterfeit checks. PNC recommends examining several physical features before depositing any check you were not expecting.

Start with the edges. Legitimate checks are torn from a check book and have at least one rough, perforated edge. If all four edges are smooth, that is a warning sign.

Look at the bank logo and address printed on the check. Compare the logo to the one on the bank’s official website. A faded or slightly off logo may indicate it was copied from another source. If the address does not match a real branch location, the check is likely fake.

Every real check also has a Magnetic Ink Character Recognition (MICR) line at the bottom. This line contains the routing number, account number, and check number printed with special magnetic ink. That ink should appear flat and dull. If the characters are raised or shiny under light, the check is counterfeit.

Check numbers should also appear in two places: the upper right corner and at the end of the MICR line. If those numbers do not match, do not deposit the check. PNC also notes that about 90% of fraudulent checks come from new accounts, so low check numbers (101 to 400 for personal checks, 1,000 to 1,500 for business checks) are a red flag.

Paper quality matters, too. Real checks are printed on heavy, matte paper with permanent ink. A quick test: wet your fingertip and lightly drag it across the printed surface. If ink smears, the check is likely fake.

Common Scams to Watch For

PNC identifies several scam patterns that are especially common right now.

The overpayment scam targets people selling goods or services online. A buyer sends a check for more than the asking price and asks the seller to wire back the difference. By the time the check bounces, the seller has already sent real money.

Sweepstakes scams involve receiving a check for a prize you never entered to win, with a request to send money back to cover processing or shipping fees.

Job scams send a “paycheck” before any work is done, then ask the new hire to return a portion via wire transfer or gift cards.

In all three cases, PNC’s guidance is straightforward: if it seems too good to be true, it probably is.

Steps to Protect Yourself

PNC’s prevention tips focus on reducing exposure and responding quickly when something goes wrong.

Pay digitally whenever possible to limit the number of checks in circulation. If you must mail a check, drop it inside a USPS facility or hand it directly to a postal worker rather than leaving it in a curbside mailbox. Follow up with the recipient to confirm it arrived.

Set up account alerts and review your bank statements regularly. Most banks allow you to view images of processed checks so you can confirm the check that cleared matches what you actually wrote.

Speed matters if fraud does occur. PNC notes that roughly 50% of stolen check images are posted for sale online within eight days of theft. The moment you spot something wrong, contact your bank to place a stop payment and freeze the account. File a police report and a separate report with the Federal Trade Commission at identitytheft.gov. Keep records of every conversation and report.

What Happens if You Deposit a Fake Check

Even consumers who act in good faith can be caught off guard. If a fake check clears initially and you spend the money, your bank will still withdraw the funds once the fraud is detected, which can take weeks. Overdraft fees may follow. In some cases, your account may be frozen or closed, and the incident can appear in banking history reports used by other institutions when you try to open a new account.

If you receive a check you believe may be fraudulent, do not cash it. Contact the issuing bank directly using a phone number from the bank’s official website, not any number printed on the check itself. If fraud is confirmed, report it to the U.S. Postal Inspection Service if it came by mail, or to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center if it was part of an online scheme.

Sources

How to Tell If a Check Is Fake, PNC Insights
Take Extra Measures to Help Prevent Check Fraud, PNC Insights

Frequently Asked Questions

According to the U.S. Treasury's Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, check fraud complaints topped two million in 2024 — a record high and a 4% increase from 2022. Checks still account for more than 20% of all noncash transactions in the U.S., which keeps them a prime target for criminals.
Inspect the physical check: legitimate checks have at least one rough, perforated edge; the bank logo and address should match the bank's official website; the MICR line at the bottom should be flat and dull, not raised or shiny; the check number should match in the upper-right corner and at the end of the MICR line; and the paper should be heavy and matte with ink that doesn't smear when you drag a wet fingertip across it. Low check numbers can also be a red flag, since about 90% of fraudulent checks come from new accounts.
Three stand out: the overpayment scam (a buyer overpays and asks you to wire back the difference before the check bounces), sweepstakes scams (a check for a prize you never entered, with a request to send money back for fees), and job scams (a 'paycheck' before any work, with a request to return part of it via wire or gift cards). If it seems too good to be true, it probably is.
If a fake check clears and you spend the money, the bank will reclaim those funds once the fraud is detected — often weeks later — and overdraft fees, account freezes, or closures can follow. Act fast: contact your bank to stop payment and freeze the account, file a police report and a report with the FTC at identitytheft.gov, and keep records of every conversation.
Pay digitally when possible, and if you must mail a check, drop it inside a USPS facility or hand it to a postal worker rather than a curbside mailbox, then confirm it arrived. Set up account alerts, review statements and processed-check images regularly, and never use a phone number printed on a suspicious check — call the issuing bank using a number from its official website.
Advertisement Weldon PC